MenuToEat.com
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
MenuToEat— Restaurant Menus Online
Privacy PolicyTermsDisclaimer

© 2026 MenuToEat.com

Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Please contact the restaurant for the most current information.

Photo of Schwarz's Supper Club in New Holstein, WI
Restaurantsteak house

Schwarz's Supper Club

New Holstein

★★★★½4.7(2,069 Google reviews)$$
W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061(920) 894-3598
Google MapsOfficial Website
🍽Menu🛵Order Online🎟Coupons🥗Dietary🔄Alternatives⭐Reviews📍Map📷Photos
🥗

Schwarz's Supper Club Dietary Guide

Programmatic allergen analysis and menu breakdown

⚠️

Important Health & Safety Notice

This dietary guide is generated programmatically by analyzing dish names, descriptions, and common culinary ingredients. If you have severe celiac disease, life-threatening food allergies, or specific medical needs, please confirm with the kitchen staff before ordering. Cross-contamination can occur in shared kitchen environments.

🌾 Gluten-Free Options (23 matches)

Dishes containing no gluten or wheat ingredients.

APPETIZERS

Blue Balls

Five chicken cordon bleu bites lightly breaded and served with ranch dressing.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$6.99

Buffalo Chicken

Eight boneless all white chicken bites, fried and shaken with your favorite sauce (Hot, BBQ, or plain) and served with ranch or blue cheese dressing.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$6.99

Quesadilla Rolls

Four sticks rolled in tortillas with Wisconsin cheese, chicken, and jalapeños and served with sour cream.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$6.99

ST. ANNA'S ONION RINGS

Schwarz's famous hand cut, hand breaded, sweet jumbo rings.

1/4 Order

(Salad Bowl)

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$5.49

SCHWARZ'S COMBOS

Mix and match any steak entree and seafood entree to create your own combo! We can create other combos not listed here; please ask your server and we will provide a price for your approval!

3 Grilled Scallops

Topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$4.99

3 Shrimp

Breaded or grilled topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$3.99

PORTERHOUSE

Porterhouse

(30-32 oz.) The largest of all T-Bones; big in size and flavor! Like two steaks in one; juicy center-cut strip steak on one side of the bone and buttery-soft tenderloin on the other, plus Schwarz's diamond cut four inch tail. This unique combination will please most any appetite!

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$45.99

T-Bone Large 26-28 oz.

Like two steaks in one; juicy center-cut strip steak on one side of the bone and buttery soft tenderloin on the other, plus Schwarz's diamond cut four inch tail. Together tastes delicious!

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$36.99

Club Steak

(18-20 oz.) A bone-in, center cut strip steak from the end of the short loin.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$24.99

Rib Eye 16-18 oz.

One of our juiciest steaks due to the rich marbling, and when cooking the juices are sealed into this tender steak.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$35.99

EXTRAS

Dinner Salad

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$3.49

Potato or Vegetable

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$3.49

SALMON

Breaded Shrimp (6 shrimp)

Fantail shrimp, deep-fried served with cocktail sauce.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$23.99

Breaded Shrimp (3 shrimp)

Fantail shrimp, deep-fried served with cocktail sauce.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$15.99

Grilled Shrimp (6 shrimp)

Large shrimp grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter and grilled.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$25.99

Grilled Shrimp (3 shrimp)

Large shrimp grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter and grilled.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$16.99

GRILLED SCALLOPS

Grilled Scallops (6 scallops)

Fresh large scallops grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$46.99

Grilled Scallops (3 scallops)

Fresh large scallops grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$28.99

Breaded Scallops (12 scallops)

Deep-fried scallops, served with cocktail sauce.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$21.99

Breaded Scallops (6 scallops)

Deep-fried scallops, served with cocktail sauce.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$15.99

WALLEYE

Tilapia

(8 oz.) Farm raised, mild tasting fish, lightly seasoned and steamed to perfection. Served with homemade dill sauce.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$16.99

Red Wine

A "ST. ANNA'S POUR" IN AN OVERSIZED GLASS

CABERNET SAUVIGNON - HORSE HEAVEN HILL "H3"

Bright red fruit and cassis, well-balanced, with a touch of oak.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$7.50

White Wine

PINOT GRIGIO - RUFFINO

Bright yellow in color, aromas of honeydew melon, with flavors of crisp fruit such as yellow apples and elegant floral notes.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$7.50
📋

View Menu

🎟️

Deals & Coupons

⭐

Reviews

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for current information.