MenuToEat.com
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
MenuToEat— Restaurant Menus Online
Privacy PolicyTermsDisclaimer

© 2026 MenuToEat.com

Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Please contact the restaurant for the most current information.

Photo of Schwarz's Supper Club in New Holstein, WI
Restaurantsteak house

Schwarz's Supper Club

New Holstein

★★★★½4.7(2,069 Google reviews)$$
W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061(920) 894-3598
Google MapsOfficial Website
🍽Menu🛵Order Online🎟Coupons🥗Dietary🔄Alternatives⭐Reviews📍Map📷Photos

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for current information.

Restaurants/New Holstein, WI
AmericanCasual DiningBar or PubHotel

Browse community photos of Schwarz's Supper Club in New Holstein, WI, including restaurant and food images when available.

Photo of Schwarz's Supper Club in New Holstein, WI (2)
Photo of Schwarz's Supper Club in New Holstein, WI (3)+7 more photos
📍Directions📞Call🌐Website🛵Order Online

About Schwarz's Supper Club

New Holstein, WI102 menu items across 28 sections

Browse the full menu for Schwarz's Supper Club, a american restaurant in New Holstein, WI. This page brings together menu prices, photos, ratings, reviews, and ordering links in one place.

Visit Schwarz's Supper Club at W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061 or call (920) 894-3598. Today's posted hours: Saturday: 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM.

More menus in New Holstein

Full Menu

28 sections, 102 items

APPETIZERS

11 items
  • Cheese Nuggets$6.99

    Served with marinara sauce.

  • Cauliflower$6.99

    Breaded with cheese and deep-fried, served with ranch dressing.

  • Italian Breaded Mozzarella Sticks$6.99

    Eight mozzarella cheese sticks breaded and served with marinara sauce.

  • Blue Balls$6.99

    Five chicken cordon bleu bites lightly breaded and served with ranch dressing.

  • Buffalo Chicken$6.99

    Eight boneless all white chicken bites, fried and shaken with your favorite sauce (Hot, BBQ, or plain) and served with ranch or blue cheese dressing.

  • Chips with French Onion Dip$6.99

    Plate of homemade chips deep-fried on order, with a light toss of sea salt and served with French Onion dip.

  • Calamari$9.99

    Lightly breaded and served with marinara sauce.

  • Buttermilk Breaded Popcorn Shrimp$7.99

    (8oz) Breaded bite-size shrimp served with cocktail sauce.

  • Shrimp Cocktail$9.99

    Four shrimp steamed on order, chilled and served with cocktail sauce.

  • Breaded Mozzarella Sticks$6.99

    mozzarella cheese sticks breaded and ved with marinara sauce.

  • Quesadilla Rolls$6.99

    Four sticks rolled in tortillas with Wisconsin cheese, chicken, and jalapeños and served with sour cream.

DINNER ENTRÉES

3 items

Mixed green salad with Wisconsin shredded cheese, radishes, croutons, and tomato with a choice of dressing at the table. Or, if you prefer, applesauce or cottage cheese. Assorted dinner rolls, relish dish and choice of potato (baked, broasted, or french fries) or fresh steamed vegetable.

  • Clam Strips$6.49

    Served with homemade cocktail sauce.

  • Tempura Shrimp$8.99

    Approximately eight lightly breaded shrimp served with a sesame ginger sauce.

  • Crab Cakes$6.99

    Two deep-fried cakes filled with stuffing and crab meat served with homemade dill sauce.

ST. ANNA'S ONION RINGS

3 items

Schwarz's famous hand cut, hand breaded, sweet jumbo rings.

  • Full Order$9.99

    (11" Plate)

  • 1/2 Order$6.99

    (9" Plate)

  • 1/4 Order$5.49

    (Salad Bowl)

COMBO PLATE

1 item

Four mozzarella sticks, onion rings, cheese nuggets, served with ranch dressing and marinara sauce.

  • Combo Plate$8.99

    Four mozzarella sticks, onion rings, cheese nuggets, served with ranch dressing and marinara sauce.

PRIME RIB BITES

1 item

Schwarz's favorite end prime rib cut to bite size pieces (served approximately medium well!!) and shaken in your favorite sauce (Hot, BBQ, or Au Jus) and served with ranch or blue cheese dressing.

  • Prime Rib Bites$9.99

    Schwarz's favorite prime rib cut to bite size pieces (served approximately medium only) and shaken in your favorite sauce (Hot, BBQ, or Au Jus) and served with ranch or blue cheese dressing.

SCHWARZ'S COMBOS

12 items

Mix and match any steak entree and seafood entree to create your own combo! We can create other combos not listed here; please ask your server and we will provide a price for your approval!

  • 3 Grilled Scallops$4.99

    Topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter

  • 3 Shrimp$3.99

    Breaded or grilled topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter

  • 6 Breaded Bay Scallops$30.99

    Breaded & deep fried

  • Lobster Tail$6.49

    (8-10 oz.) Coldwater Canadian tail

  • Small Ribs$3.99

    (6-7 ribs)

  • Petite Baked Haddock$2.99

    (7 oz.)

  • Petite Rib Eye

    (8-10 oz.)

  • Petite Tenderloin

    (8 oz.) Extra $2.00

  • Petite Prime Rib

    (8-10 oz.)

  • Small Tip

    (6 oz.)

  • Medium Tips

    (8-10 oz.) Extra $2.00

  • 6 Breaded Scallops$2.99

    Breaded & deep fried

PORTERHOUSE

6 items
  • Porterhouse$45.99

    (30-32 oz.) The largest of all T-Bones; big in size and flavor! Like two steaks in one; juicy center-cut strip steak on one side of the bone and buttery-soft tenderloin on the other, plus Schwarz's diamond cut four inch tail. This unique combination will please most any appetite!

  • T-Bone Large 26-28 oz.$36.99

    Like two steaks in one; juicy center-cut strip steak on one side of the bone and buttery soft tenderloin on the other, plus Schwarz's diamond cut four inch tail. Together tastes delicious!

  • T-Bone Regular 22-24 oz.$30.99
  • Club Steak$24.99

    (18-20 oz.) A bone-in, center cut strip steak from the end of the short loin.

  • Rib Eye 16-18 oz.$35.99

    One of our juiciest steaks due to the rich marbling, and when cooking the juices are sealed into this tender steak.

  • Rib Eye 10 oz.$26.99

ST. ANNA'S PRIME RIB

5 items
  • Petite Cut$25.99

    (10-12 oz.)

  • Queen Cut$36.99

    (16-18 oz.)

  • King Cut$45.99

    (24-26 oz.)

  • Schwarz's Cut$55.99

    (32-34 oz.)

  • Prime Rib for Two$79.99

    (50-52 oz.)

Tenderloin

2 items
  • Tenderloin 16 oz.$48.99

    The most tender cut of beef! Buttery-soft with delicate flavor and a light smooth texture, this cut is sure to melt in your mouth!

  • Tenderloin 8 oz.$34.99

    The most tender cut of beef! Buttery-soft with delicate flavor and a light smooth texture, this cut is sure to melt in your mouth!

New York Strip

2 items
  • New York Strip 16 oz.$31.99

    Rich, full beef taste with a bit of firmness; boneless and cut from the top of the loin.

  • New York Strip 8-10 oz.$24.99

    Rich, full beef taste with a bit of firmness; boneless and cut from the top of the loin.

SIRLOIN TIPS

3 items

Boneless, butt tenderloin fillets, one-inch thick from the loin with a rich beef flavor.

  • Small$21.99

    (4-6 oz.) One Fillet

  • Medium$29.99

    (8 oz.) Two Fillets

  • Large$40.99

    (16 oz.) Three to Four Fillets

Double Cut Cowboy Rib Eye

1 item
  • Double Cut Cowboy Rib Eye$47.99

    Bone-in and frenched, this double cut rib eye weighs in at a thick 32 ounces. A cut with intense taste because of more marbling, sealed with juicy tenderness.

Chopped Sirloin

2 items
  • Chopped Sirloin 16-20 oz.$17.99

    Ground hamburger fresh in-house; a delicious threesome of beef, rib eye, sirloin and tenderloin.

  • Chopped Sirloin 8-10 oz.$14.99

    Ground hamburger fresh in-house; a delicious threesome of beef, rib eye, sirloin and tenderloin.

EXTRAS

3 items
  • Dinner Salad$3.49
  • Potato or Vegetable$3.49
  • Extra Plate$3.49

    (Includes relish dish and dinner rolls)

ADD-ONS

2 items
  • Schwarz's Mushroom Medley$6.99

    Fresh crimini, button, and portabella mushrooms lightly seasoned and roasted in butter and olive oil.

  • Fried Onion Hearts$3.99

SALMON

5 items
  • Salmon$25.99

    (8 oz.) Atlantic salmon farm raised from Norway. Topped with a homemade flavored butter or homemade teriyaki sauce, served with dill sauce.

  • Breaded Shrimp (6 shrimp)$23.99

    Fantail shrimp, deep-fried served with cocktail sauce.

  • Breaded Shrimp (3 shrimp)$15.99

    Fantail shrimp, deep-fried served with cocktail sauce.

  • Grilled Shrimp (6 shrimp)$25.99

    Large shrimp grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter and grilled.

  • Grilled Shrimp (3 shrimp)$16.99

    Large shrimp grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter and grilled.

GRILLED SCALLOPS

4 items
  • Grilled Scallops (6 scallops)$46.99

    Fresh large scallops grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter.

  • Grilled Scallops (3 scallops)$28.99

    Fresh large scallops grilled, topped with Pesto-garlic, pine nut butter.

  • Breaded Scallops (12 scallops)$21.99

    Deep-fried scallops, served with cocktail sauce.

  • Breaded Scallops (6 scallops)$15.99

    Deep-fried scallops, served with cocktail sauce.

SEA BASS

1 item
  • Sea Bass$39.99

    (8 oz.) Chilean Sea Bass pan seared, then baked with homemade lemon caper sauce.

KING KONG CRAB LEGS

1 item
  • King Kong Crab LegsMARKET PRICE

    (24 oz.) Wild caught Alaskan king crab legs steamed to tender perfection and served with melted butter.

LOBSTER

2 items

We serve only cold water Canadian tails, steamed and served with melted butter.

  • 1 Tail (8-10 oz.)$52.99
  • 2 Tails$82.99

WALLEYE

4 items
  • Walleye$23.99

    (8-10 oz.) Wild caught Canadian walleye, lightly breaded and deep fried or lightly buttered and steamed to perfection.

  • Tilapia$16.99

    (8 oz.) Farm raised, mild tasting fish, lightly seasoned and steamed to perfection. Served with homemade dill sauce.

  • Haddock (14 oz.)$21.99

    Lightly seasoned and steamed to perfection, served with drawn butter.

  • Haddock (7 oz.)$16.99

    Lightly seasoned and steamed to perfection, served with drawn butter.

FRESH LAKE PERCH

3 items

A Wisconsin tradition, lightly breaded and fried to a golden perfection. Beer battered is available on Fridays only.

  • 2 Fillets$19.99
  • 3 Fillets$25.99
  • 5 Fillets$35.99

MARTINIS

4 items
  • Key Lime

    Midori, Captain Morgan, Dr. McGillicuddy Vanilla, Pineapple Juice and Cream

  • Cosmo

    Absolut Citron Vodka, DeKuyper Triple Sec and Cranberry Juice

  • Chocolate Martini

    Baileys Chocolate, Baileys Irish Cream and Smirnoff Vanilla Vodka

  • Lemon Drop

    Absolut Citron Vodka, Splash of Sweet & Sour and Lemonade

AFTER DINNER DRINKS

7 items
  • Grasshopper

    DeKuyper Créme de Menthe and Ice Cream

  • Pink Squirrel

    DeKuyper Créme de Almond, DeKuyper Créme de Cocoa White and Ice Cream

  • Desperate Housewife

    DeKuyper Razzmatazz, Baileys Irish Cream, Smirnoff Vanilla Vodka, Baileys Chocolate and Ice Cream

  • Banana Banshee

    DeKuyper Créme de Banana, DeKuyper Créme de Cocoa White and Ice Cream

  • Brandy Alexxander

    Christian Brothers Brandy, DeKuyper Créme de Cocoa Dark and Ice Cream

  • Salted Caramel Alexander

    Ole Smoky Salted Caramel Whiskey, DeKuyper Créme de Cocoa White and Ice Cream

  • Cold Turkey

    Baileys Irish Cream, DeKuyper Buttershots and Ice Cream

Red Wine

5 items

A "ST. ANNA'S POUR" IN AN OVERSIZED GLASS

  • 402.RED BLEND - Q.S.S. RARE$7.50

    The Rare red wine blend is intense garnet color, with a floral and spicy aroma that comes from the barrel aging. Smooth and elegant.

  • 403.ORGANIC MALBEC - THE SHOW$7.50

    The Show Malbec has smooth tannins, a velvety texture and a long, lingering finish.

  • 405.PINOT NOIR - TRINITY OAKS$7.50

    Intense berry flavors with rich finish.

  • 404.MERLOT - 14 HANDS$7.50

    Blackberry with touches of cherry and spice.

  • 401.CABERNET SAUVIGNON - HORSE HEAVEN HILL "H3"$7.50

    Bright red fruit and cassis, well-balanced, with a touch of oak.

Sparkling Wine

1 item
  • 301.ASTI - MARTINI & ROSSI single serve$6.00

    Naturally sweet sparkling wine with a wonderful texture.

White Wine

5 items
  • 101.SAUVIGNON BLANC - KIM CRAWFORD$7.50

    A great wine from New Zealand with juicy flavors of grapefruit and lemon zest.

  • 103.PINOT GRIGIO - RUFFINO$7.50

    Bright yellow in color, aromas of honeydew melon, with flavors of crisp fruit such as yellow apples and elegant floral notes.

  • 104.CHARDONNAY - KENDALL-JACKSON VINTNER'S RESERVE$7.50

    Tropical flavors such as mango and pineapple dance with aromas of peach, apple, and pear.

  • 105.MOSCATO - JACOB'S CREEK$7.50

    Ripe peaches and honeysuckle flavors lead the way on this amazingly sweet wine.

  • 109.RIESLING - BAUER HAUS$7.50

    A sweet, superbly balanced German wine.

DINNER ENTREES

3 items

Mixed green salad with Wisconsin shredded cheese, radishes, croutons, and tomato with a choice of dressing at the table. Or, if you prefer, applesauce or cottage cheese. Assorted dinner rolls, relish dish and choice of potato (baked, broasted, or french fries) or fresh steamed vegetable.

  • Clam Strips$6.49

    Served with homemade cocktail sauce.

  • Tempura Shrimp$8.99

    Approximately eight lightly breaded shrimp served with a sesame ginger sauce.

  • Crab Cakes$6.99

    Two deep-fried cakes filled with stuffing and crab meat served with homemade dill sauce.

Hours

Wednesday: 3:30 PM - 8:30 PM
Thursday: 3:30 PM - 8:30 PM
Friday: 3:30 PM - 8:30 PM
Saturday: 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Sunday: 2:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Wed, Thu: 15:30 - 20:00
Sunday: 2:30 PM - 8:00 PM
🛵

Order Online

Delivery & takeout

🎟️

Coupons & Deals

Find savings

⭐

Read Reviews

Yelp, Google, TripAdvisor

📍

Map & Location

Get directions

📸

View Photos

10 photos

Explore More MenuToEat Restaurants

Handpicked by cuisine, location, and menu similarity.

Browse All

Ranch Restaurant

Greeley, CO

Restaurant★ 4.6

Peach blossom

Rochester, NY

Restaurant★ 4.8

Momotombo

Silverthorne, CO

Restaurant★ 4.6

Pancho’s Birria y Mas

Lakewood, CO

Restaurant★ 4.6

Know Before You Go

Visit details worth checking

Checked May 18, 2026

Use this section to quickly check service details, dietary notes, and the best available menu, booking, review, map, and website links for Schwarz's Supper Club.

Official websiteGet directionsView on Google MapsGoogle reviewsSee photos