MenuToEat.com
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
MenuToEat— Restaurant Menus Online
Privacy PolicyTermsDisclaimer

© 2026 MenuToEat.com

Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Please contact the restaurant for the most current information.

Photo of Extra Extra Pizza in Buffalo, NY
Pizzapizza restaurant

Extra Extra Pizza

Five Points, Buffalo

★★★★½4.7(346 Google reviews)
549 W Utica St, Buffalo, NY 14213(716) 248-2994
Dine-inTakeoutMonday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM
Google MapsOfficial Website
🍽Menu🛵Order Online🎟Coupons🥗Dietary🔄Alternatives⭐Reviews📍Map📷Photos

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for current information.

Restaurants/Buffalo, NY/Pizza
Pizza

Browse community photos of Extra Extra Pizza in Buffalo, NY, including restaurant and food images when available.

Photo of Extra Extra Pizza in Buffalo, NY (2)
Photo of Extra Extra Pizza in Buffalo, NY (3)+7 more photos
MenuToEat Journal

Slice of Buffalo Life: Extra Extra Pizza and Lafayette Square Serendipity

A perfect pizza joint discovered while exploring downtown Buffalo. Extra Extra Pizza is more than a meal; it's a taste of the city's vibrant character.

Read the story →
📍Directions📞Call🌐Website🛵Order Online

About Extra Extra Pizza

Buffalo, NY186 menu items across 22 sections

Browse the full menu for Extra Extra Pizza, a pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY. This page brings together menu prices, photos, ratings, reviews, and ordering links in one place.

Visit Extra Extra Pizza at 549 W Utica St, Buffalo, NY 14213 or call (716) 248-2994. Today's posted hours: Monday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM.

More menus in BuffaloMore Pizza menus in Buffalo

Full Menu

22 sections, 186 items

Sweet Wine

4 items
  • fresh grapes, honeysuckle$56.00
  • Peach jam, lemonade from the fair$38.00
  • raspberry, candied orange$45.00
  • candy from Grandma's pocket$43.00

Old Signature Pizzas

14 items
  • Red Sauce
  • 1.pepperoni, jalapeño, hot maple
  • 3.fresh mozz, meatball, onion
  • 9.sausage, onion, sweet pepper
  • 11.chili relish, pickled red onion, pickled jalapeño
  • 13.pickled banana pepper, ricotta, seasoned breadcrumbs
  • 15.fresh mozz, vodka sauce, cup n char pepperoni
  • White Sauce
  • 2.aged mozz, diced tomatoes, onions
  • 4.aged mozz, preserved eggplant, basl
  • 6.aged mozz, pesto, ricotta, lemon zest
  • 10.aged mozz, chicken finger, hot sauce (+bleu cheese $1)
  • 16.aged mozz, cracked pink peppercorns, lots of romano
  • 18.aged mozz, chicken finger, bacon, ranch, parsley

Cocktails

8 items
  • Easy Drinking
  • 7.gin or tequila, centerb
  • 15.vodka, peach liqueur
  • 17.tequila, bitter red liq
  • 18.vodka, passionfruit
  • 26.Haitian rhum, basil,
  • 34.rum, amaro, lime, g
  • 46.Italian vodka, red

Soda Shop Favs

4 items
  • 11.whiskey, fernet, c
  • 14.Sweet vermouth
  • 23.tequila, dry vern
  • 32.dry lambrusco,

Spirit Forward

5 items
  • 12.gin, bianco ver
  • 20.rye, amaro, ar
  • 21.bourbon, ama
  • 25.bourbon, spic
  • 38.bourbon, Cu

Low Proof

6 items
  • 14.sweet verm
  • 22.dry Lambru
  • 31.light beer,
  • 33.bianco ver
  • 41.aperitivo,
  • 45.Elderflow

No Proof

2 items
  • 3.white or r
  • 9.N/A lager

PIZZA

32 items

Choose White or Red Sauce All pizzas come with aged mozz

  • Medium$17.00
  • Large$22.00
  • Sicilian Style$26.00
  • Gluten Free$20.00
  • Pepperoni$3.00
  • Spicy Sausage$3.00
  • Meatballs$3.00
  • Chicken Fingers$5.00
  • Anchovies$3.00
  • Vegan Pepperoni$5.00

    (from Strong Hearts)

  • Onions$1.00
  • Flat 12 Mushrooms$6.00
  • Oil-preserved Eggplant$2.00
  • Pickled Jalapenos$2.00
  • Banana Peppers$2.00
  • Sweet peppers$3.00
  • Olives$2.00
  • Garlic$0.50
  • Fresh Basil$2.00
  • Diced tomato$2.00
  • Ricotta$2.50
  • Pesto$3.00
  • Hot Maple$1.00
  • Hot sauce$1.00
  • Sub Fresh Mozzarella$2.00
  • Sub Vegan Cheese$3.00
  • Blue Cheese, Chili Relish$1.00

    Sides:

  • White Anchovies$3.00
  • Medium$16.00
  • Sicilian Style$24.00
  • Hot peppers$2.00

    /$3

  • Sides: Blue Cheese, Chili Relish$1.00

OUR PICKS

4 items
  • 13.Pizza Number$23.00

    Stuffed Banana Pepper red sauce, aged mozzarella, house pickled banana peppers, ricotta, seasoned breadcrumbs

  • 14.Pizza Number$24.00

    Chicago Beef white sauce, aged mozzarella, garlic, braised beef, giardiniera

  • Pizza Number 11$22.00

    red sauce, aged mozzarella, garlic, red onion, jalapeno, chili relish, crispy shallot

  • Pizza Number 12$24.00

    olive oil, garlic, mortadella, onion, whole grain mustard

ΠΟΤ-ΡΙΖZA

6 items
  • Bread+ Butter$4.00

    *Add red sauce $2*

  • Salad$13.00

    romaine, carrot, pickled red onion, marinated chickpeas, croutons, romano, vinaigrette

  • Olives$8.00

    House marinade, medley of black and green olives

  • Meatballs$9.00

    3, served with red sauce and romano

  • Giardiniera$4.00

    Crunchy pickled veggies

  • Cheesy Garlic Bread$11.00

    Housemade hoagie roll, butter, garlic, served with red sauce *Make it vegan for $2*

BEER

12 items
  • BUDWEISER$4.00
  • CORONA PREMIER$6.00
  • GRAFT CIDER$7.00
  • WILD ARC SPRITZER$8.00
  • TALEA ITALIAN PILSNER$9.00
  • WAYLAND GUAVA SOUR$7.00
  • FIDDLEHEAD IPA$8.00
  • ALLAGASH WHITE$7.00
  • CBW BROWN ALE$6.00
  • LAGUNITAS HOP WATER N/A$4.00
  • BUSCH N/A$5.00
  • ATHLETIC BREWING N/A$7.00

WINE

14 items
  • RACY + REFRESHING: PROSECCO'S COOLER COUSIN$11.00
  • TANGY + BRIGHT: GREEN APPLE SKINS, GRAPEFRUIT$11.00
  • CREATIVE EXPRESSIVE: BEGONIAS, ORANGE PEELS$12.00
  • FRESH + VIBRANT: WATERMELON JOLLY RANCHERS$7.00
  • GENTLE + REFINED: RASPBERRY CHIFFON CAKE$11.00
  • INKY + FIZZY: #PIZZAWINE, BALSAMIC$9.00
  • JUICY LIGHT: FRUIT PUNCH, CRAN RAZZ JUICE$10.00
  • BOLD + GRACEFUL: BLACK CHERRY, EARTHY$10.00
  • DARK + RICH: BLACKBERRY, COFFEE$11.00
  • RACY + REFRESHING: PROSECCO'S COOLER COUSIN$12.00
  • SOPHISTICATED + POLISHED: DAISIES, LIME$10.00
  • LAYERED + NUANCED: PEACH ICED TEA, PAPAYA$14.00
  • ELEGANT + DRY: WHITE PEACH, CRUSHED BERRIES$9.00
  • PLUSH + EASY: BLACK CHERRY$9.00

NOT-WINE

13 items

THE SUMMER OF SPRITZ

  • 30.DRINK NUMBER$13.00

    Watermelon gin, lemon, rosé

  • 31.DRINK NUMBER$10.00

    Budweiser, Faccia Brutto Aperitivo

  • 32.DRINK NUMBER$9.00

    Dry lambrusco, cola

  • 33.DRINK NUMBER$11.00

    Bianco Vermouth, Amaro Rubino, soda

  • 34.DRINK NUMBER$10.00

    Rum, Ercole Amaro, Noveis Amaro, lime, ginger beer

  • 35.DRINK NUMBER$13.00

    Rose vermouth, bitter bianco, sparkling wine

  • 36.DRINK NUMBER$12.00

    Non-alcoholic bourbon, lemon, sugar, non-alcoholic red wine float

  • 14.DRINK NUMBER$10.00

    Sweet Vermouth, cherry, amaro choose: lemon-lime or cola

  • 15.DRINK NUMBER$11.00

    Vodka, peach, lemon, orange wine

  • 16.DRINK NUMBER$9.00

    Rum, condensed milk, lime, lemon, sugar

  • 17.DRINK NUMBER$9.00

    Tequila, Rosen Bitter, lime, sugar

  • 18.DRINK NUMBER$13.00

    Vodka, vanilla bean, passionfruit, lemon, sugar, sparkling wine

  • 19.DRINK NUMBER$8.00

    N/A! Tropical green tea, Lyre's Italian Orange, pineapple, lime, sugar

SPIRIT-FREE

19 items
  • 36.DRINK NUMBER$12.00

    Non-alcoholic bourbon, lemon, sugar, non-alcoholic red wine

  • Lagunitas Hop Water$4.00

    CANS & BOTTLES

  • Busch NA$5.00
  • Athletic Brewing$7.00
  • Phony Negroni$10.00
  • Amaro Spritz$10.00
  • Pellegrino 1L$8.00
  • Proxies Sparkling Rose$11.00
  • Unified Ferments Jasmine Kombucha$55.00
  • Proxies Pink Salt Rosé$60.00
  • Proxies Red Ember$11.00
  • Cola$3.00

    SOFT DRINKS

  • Diet Cola$3.00
  • Lemon Lime$3.00
  • Ginger Ale$3.00
  • Grape$3.00
  • Loganberry$3.00
  • Lemonade$4.00
  • Basil Lemonade$5.00

SPIRITS

5 items
  • White Verjus$7.00
  • Red Verjus$7.00
  • Ritual Gin$6.00
  • Ritual Tequila$6.00
  • Lyre's Italian Orange$6.00

SWEET

7 items
  • LEITZ OFF DRY RIESLING CAN$13.00
  • G.D. VAJRA MOSCATO D'ASTI$26.00
  • EMMA OFF DRY LAMBRUSCO$45.00
  • WALCHER AMARETTO$6.00
  • VECCHIA LIMONCINO$4.00
  • STAMBECCO CHERRY AMARO$6.00
  • 5.DRINK NUMBER$12.00

    RYE, BUTTER WASHED AMARI, ESPRESSO, SALT

SWETS

1 item
  • Soft serve ice cream$6.00

    mocha, sweet cream, or a twist! cones and dishes available

NOT-PIZZA

7 items
  • Bread+Butter$4.00
  • Salad$13.00

    romaine, carrot, pickled red onion, marinated chickpeas, croutons, romano, vinaigrette

  • Olives$8.00

    House marinade, medley of black and green olives

  • Meatballs$9.00

    3, served with red sauce and romano

  • Cheesy Garlic Bread$11.00

    housemade hoagie roll, butter, garlic, mozzarella served with red sauce *Make it vegan for $2*

  • Salad$12.00

    spring mix, carrot, pickled red onion, marinated chickpeas, croutons, romano, vinaigrette

  • Bread+ Butter$4.00

    Add red sauce $2

Pizza Number 7

1 item
  • Medium / Large / Sicilian$23.00

Pizza Number 8

1 item
  • Medium/Large / Sicilian$25.00

Menu

20 items
  • Budweiser$4.00
  • Busch N/A$5.00
  • Athletic Brewing N/A$7.00
  • Van Trapp Pilsner$7.00
  • Lagunitas Hop Water N/A$4.00
  • Talea Pink Lemonade Lager$9.00
  • CBW Good Neighbors IPA$6.00
  • Two Robbers Craft Seltzer$7.00
  • Anderson Valley Gose$7.00
  • Wayland Baby Marzen$7.00
  • Fiddlehead IPA$8.00
  • Allagash White$7.00
  • LEITZ OFF DRY RIESLING CAN$13.00
  • G.D. VAJRA MOSCATO D'ASTI$26.00
  • EMMA OFF DRY LAMBRUSCO$45.00
  • RED TAIL RIDGE GOOD KARMA RIESLING$50.00
  • FRANCOLI FERNET$5.00
  • VECCHIA AMARO DEL CAPO$6.00
  • STREGA$9.00
  • 5.DRINK NUMBER$12.00

    RYE, BUTTER WASHED AMARI, ESPRESSO, SALT

SWEETS

1 item
  • Soft serve ice cream$6.00

    vanilla or signature

Hours

Monday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 5:00 – 9:00 PM
Friday: 12:00 – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 12:00 – 10:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
Dine-in AvailableTakeout Available
🛵

Order Online

Delivery & takeout

🎟️

Coupons & Deals

Find savings

⭐

Read Reviews

Yelp, Google, TripAdvisor

📍

Map & Location

Get directions

📸

View Photos

10 photos

Explore More MenuToEat Restaurants

Handpicked by cuisine, location, and menu similarity.

Browse All

Santo Pulpo

San José del Cabo, BCS

Restaurant★ 4.4

Lonchería Leo

Tulum, ROO

Restaurant★ 4.8

Mariscos Y Molcajetes Los Mochis

Cabo San Lucas, BCS

Restaurant★ 4.4

La K-trina

Baja California, BCS

Restaurant★ 4.8

Know Before You Go

Visit details worth checking

Use this section to quickly check service details, dietary notes, and the best available menu, booking, review, map, and website links for Extra Extra Pizza.

ServiceDine-in availableTakeout available
Official websiteGet directionsView on Google MapsGoogle reviewsSee photos

Around The Area

What's nearby

Five Points, Buffalomap context

Extra Extra Pizza is in Five Points, Buffalo. If you're getting your bearings, it is in Five Points.

in Five Points