MenuToEat.com
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
MenuToEat— Restaurant Menus Online
Privacy PolicyTermsDisclaimer

© 2026 MenuToEat.com

Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Please contact the restaurant for the most current information.

Photo of The Old Mill Pottery House Café in Pigeon Forge, TN
Southernamerican restaurant

The Old Mill Pottery House Café

Pigeon Forge

Housemade baked goods from grain ground at an on-site mill along with classic Southern comfort food.

★★★★½4.7(7,334 Google reviews)$$

“Housemade baked goods from grain ground at an on-site mill along with classic Southern comfort food.”

3341 Old Mill St, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863(865) 453-6002
Dine-inTakeoutMonday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
Google MapsOfficial Website
🍽Menu🛵Order Online🎟Coupons🥗Dietary🔄Alternatives⭐Reviews📍Map📷Photos
🥗

The Old Mill Pottery House Café Dietary Guide

Programmatic allergen analysis and menu breakdown

⚠️

Important Health & Safety Notice

This dietary guide is generated programmatically by analyzing dish names, descriptions, and common culinary ingredients. If you have severe celiac disease, life-threatening food allergies, or specific medical needs, please confirm with the kitchen staff before ordering. Cross-contamination can occur in shared kitchen environments.

🌾 Gluten-Free Options (36 matches)

Dishes containing no gluten or wheat ingredients.

CAFE SPECIALS

OLD MILL'S CHOPPED STEAK*

10oz grilled Black Angus ground beef topped with sautéed mushrooms and onions. Served with mashed potatoes and cinnamon apples.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$16.99

STIR FRY VEGTABLES

Snap peas, broccoli, cauliflower, mushrooms, bell pepper, carrots, red onion and cabbage stir-fried in our special sauce. Served over a bed of rice.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$11.49

CAROLINA BBQ PORK PLATE

Carolina-style hickory smoked barbecue pulled pork with The Old Mill's BBQ Sauce. Served with steak fries, coleslaw and an Old Mill jalapeño hoe cake.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$15.49

GRILLED CHICKEN BREASTS

Two grilled, natural cage free chicken breasts served over a bed of rice. Served with steamed broccoli.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$17.99

CAFE CHICKEN FLORENTINE

Two grilled chicken breasts topped with sautéed spinach, red onions, grape tomatoes, our creamy spinach artichoke cheese sauce and parmesan cheese. Served with steamed broccoli.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$20.99

SIGNATURE SANDWICHES

CLASSIC CHICKEN CLUB

Grilled chicken breast, cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and red onion on a grilled kaiser roll. Served with steak fries.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$14.99

RIBEYE STEAK SANDWICH

Grilled Black Angus ribeye on a fresh-baked hoagie with lettuce, tomato and red onions. Seryed with steak fries.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$21.99

BLACK ANGUS BURGERS

Served with steak fries and a pickle.

THE POTTER'S CHEESEBURGER

Topped with lettuce, tomato, red onions and choice of: cheddar, Swiss, American, provolone or blue cheese crumbles. Served on a grilled cornmeal-dusted kaiser roll.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$14.49

SMOKEHOUSE BURGER

Basted in BBQ sauce and topped with sautéed onions, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and cheddar cheese. Served on a grilled cornmeal-dusted kaiser roll.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$15.49

KIDS MENU

12 and younger please. Served with a soft drink and choice of steak fries, celery & carrots or fresh fruit cup.

GRILLED CHEESE

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$4.99

OLD MILL CORN DOG

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$4.99

CHICKEN TENDERS

Choice of fried or grilled chicken tenders.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$7.49

APPETIZERS

FRIED GREEN TOMATOES

Made with The Old Mill's Fried Green Tomato Breading. Served with our avocado ranch dressing.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$10.99

LOADED POTATO CHIPS

House fried crispy potato chips topped with melted cheddar jack cheese, chopped bacon, scallions and sour cream. Served with our avocado ranch dressing for dipping.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$12.49

CHICKEN LIVERS

Lightly breaded, deep fried and topped with caramelized onions. Served with our tangy "Come Back" dipping sauce.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$9.99

BLACK BEAN SPRING ROLLS

Black beans, cheese and seasoning wrapped in an egg roll and deep fried. Served with our Old Mill's chipotle ranch dressing.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$11.99

GRILLED SALMON CAKES

Fresh salmon mixed with cracker crumbs and seasonings. Served with our tangy "Come Back" sauce and cucumber dill sauce.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$11.99

HEARTY SOUPS

Served with fresh baked bread.

LOADED BAKED POTATO

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$6.49

SIDE DISHES

Svastable a la carte for 4.49

STEAK FRIES

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

HOMEMADE POTATO CHIPS

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

JALAPEÑO CORN PUDDING

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

GARDEN RICE

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

FRESH FRUIT CUP

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

BAKED POTATO

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

CUCUMBER TOMATO SALAD

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

BAKED SWEET POTATO

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

LOADED SIDES

Get them loaded! Add cheese, bacon, and green onions to any of the following items for an additional.99

BAKED POTATO

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

STEAK FRIES

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

POTATO CHIPS

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

THE MILLER'S SELECTIONS

Featuring ingredients ground at our bistoric, water generated mill.

CHICKEN GUMBO & GRITS

Chicken breast cooked with tomatoes, okra and Creole seasoning served on The Old Mill's creamy cheddar cheese grits. Served with an Old Mill jalapeño hoe cake.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$13.99

FRIED CATFISH FILETS

U.S. farm raised catfish hand tossed in The Old Mill's Popcorn Breading and fried to a golden brown. Served with a fresh cucumber dill sauce, steak fries and coleslaw.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$17.49

BREADED CHICKEN TENDERS

Hand breaded with The Old Mill's Chicken Breading. Served with honey mustard dressing, coleslaw and steak fries. Buffalo style with blue cheese dressing available upon request.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$15.99

STEAKS & CHOPS

Served with a house salad and choice of side dish.

BACON & BLUE CHOPPED STEAK*

10oz Black Angus ground chuck topped with crisp crumbled bacon and melted blue cheese crumbles.

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$18.49

SIGNATURE QUICHE PLATES

A longtime locals favorite! Pick your flavor and side dish. Served with cinnamon raisin pecan bread.

QUICHE + POTTERY HOUSE SALAD

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$12.49

QUICHE + FRESH FRUIT

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$13.99

QUICHE + STRAWBERRY SPINACH SALAD

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$13.99
📋

View Menu

🎟️

Deals & Coupons

⭐

Reviews

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for current information.