MenuToEat.com
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
Browse MenusFeaturedCitiesCuisines
MenuToEat— Restaurant Menus Online
Privacy PolicyTermsDisclaimer

© 2026 MenuToEat.com

Prices and menu items are subject to change without notice. Please contact the restaurant for the most current information.

Photo of Secret Sandwich Society in Fayetteville, WV
Sandwichsandwich shop

Secret Sandwich Society

Fayetteville

Rustic-style tavern featuring creative sandwiches, plus soup, salad, beer, cider & live music.

★★★★½4.6(2,785 Google reviews)$$

“Rustic-style tavern featuring creative sandwiches, plus soup, salad, beer, cider & live music.”

103 Keller Ave, Fayetteville, WV 25840(304) 574-4777
Dine-inTakeoutMonday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Google MapsOfficial Website
🍽Menu🛵Order Online🎟Coupons🥗Dietary🔄Alternatives⭐Reviews📍Map📷Photos
🥗

Secret Sandwich Society Dietary Guide

Programmatic allergen analysis and menu breakdown

⚠️

Important Health & Safety Notice

This dietary guide is generated programmatically by analyzing dish names, descriptions, and common culinary ingredients. If you have severe celiac disease, life-threatening food allergies, or specific medical needs, please confirm with the kitchen staff before ordering. Cross-contamination can occur in shared kitchen environments.

🌾 Gluten-Free Options (8 matches)

Dishes containing no gluten or wheat ingredients.

Secrets

Flavors of Fall Experience all the fall vibes in our new cocktail menu.

CARDAMOM CONSPIRACY

Bombay Sapphire Gin, Aperol, lemon, rosemary simple, egg white froth, bitter drops (anytime aperitif)

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$13

Sandwiches

Served with Society Chips & homemade pickle. Added charge for upgrading to Fries $2, or Parmesan truffle fries $2.5. Sub plant-based and gluten free bun for $1.5.

LADY BIRD

roasted chicken breast, bacon, chipotle mayo, Society Pickles, lettuce, tomato & red onions on a toasted potato roll

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$16

TRUMAN

turkey, peach jam, blue cheese spread & crispy onions on a toasted potato roll

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$14.5

KENNEDY

slow roasted pork shoulder, Society Pickles, swiss, roasted garlic mayo & horseradish on a butter toasted potato roll

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$14

ADAMS

slow roasted pork shoulder, honey butter, pimento cheese, Society Pickles & jalapeño on a toasted potato roll

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$14.5

DELANO

fried fish, tartar sauce, greens, red onion and tomato on toasted potato roll

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$15

Starters & Shares

HOT CHICKEN WINGS

spicy fried, hot honey-buffalo classic, buffalo or smoky BBQ, served with with parmesan ranch

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$14

Salads

Homemade dressings: Green Goddess (GF), Parmesan Ranch (GF) & Lemon Caesar*(GF) Balsamic (GF, DF) & Red Wine Vinaigrette (GF, DF) Add protein with: fried chicken breast $6 hard boiled egg $2

ELEANOR

our Martha salad with bacon, blue cheese & hard boiled egg tossed in our Green Goddess dressing

✓ Naturally Gluten-Free (Based on general ingredients)

$13.5
📋

View Menu

🎟️

Deals & Coupons

⭐

Reviews

Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for current information.