Rustic-style tavern featuring creative sandwiches, plus soup, salad, beer, cider & live music.
“Rustic-style tavern featuring creative sandwiches, plus soup, salad, beer, cider & live music.”
Prices and menu items are subject to change. Contact the restaurant for current information.
Browse community photos of Secret Sandwich Society in Fayetteville, WV, including restaurant and food images when available.
Flavors of Fall Experience all the fall vibes in our new cocktail menu.
House-made Limoncello, St. Germain Elderflower liqueur, grapefruit, lemon, soda water (liquid sunshine, citrusy, happiness in a glass)
Vida Mezcal, Jose Cuervo Blanco Tequila, blood orange, agave, tonic (fierce, wild, tantalizing)
Espolon Reposado, Absinthe rinse, turbinado sugar cube, Ango & Peychaud bitters (classic, herbal, transcending)
Bombay Sapphire Gin, Aperol, lemon, rosemary simple, egg white froth, bitter drops (anytime aperitif)
Tito's Vodka, Ginger Beer, lime, habanero syrup
Jim Beam Rye Whiskey, ginger syrup, lemon, Angostura bitters, egg white (ginger biscuits, black pepper, lemon)
Old Forester 100 Bourbon, maple syrup, black walnut bitters (complicated, intriguing)
Served with Society Chips & homemade pickle. Added charge for upgrading to Fries $2, or Parmesan truffle fries $2.5. Sub plant-based and gluten free bun for $1.5.
pastrami, swiss, sauerkraut & 1,000 island on butter toasted rye Also tasty with turkey!
roasted chicken breast, bacon, chipotle mayo, Society Pickles, lettuce, tomato & red onions on a toasted potato roll
turkey, peach jam, blue cheese spread & crispy onions on a toasted potato roll
slow roasted pork shoulder, Society Pickles, swiss, roasted garlic mayo & horseradish on a butter toasted potato roll
roast beef, bacon, horseradish mayo, white cheddar, lettuce, tomato & red onions on a toasted baguette
slow roasted pork shoulder, honey butter, pimento cheese, Society Pickles & jalapeño on a toasted potato roll
fried chicken breast, honey butter, swiss, Society Pickles & greens on a toasted potato roll
swiss, provolone, white cheddar, sautéed kale & marinated roasted red peppers on butter toasted sourdough
ham, white cheddar, apple, rosemary mayo & greens on a toasted baguette
fried chicken breast, ham, swiss, blue cheese spread & honey mustard on a toasted potato roll
turkey, rosemary mayo, provolone, marinated roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato & red onion on toasted sourdough
breaded and fried eggplant, homemade marinara, provolone, fresh mozzarella and parmesan served on a toasted baguette Also tasty with fried chicken! add $3
ham, mortadella, provolone, cherry peppers, lettuce, tomato, red onion, roasted garlic mayo & red wine vinaigrette on a toasted baguette
fried fish, tartar sauce, greens, red onion and tomato on toasted potato roll
breaded & fried eggplant, greens, roasted garlic mayo, provolone, cherry peppers & red onions on a toasted baguette Also tasty with fried chicken! add $3
*We proudly use certified angus beef and plant-based Beyond Beef burgers (sub plant-based for beef for an additional charge). *May be served raw or undercooked; consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Served pink or no pink on a toasted potato roll with Society Fries & homemade pickle. Sub plant-based Beyond Beef patty $3.5. Add a fried egg $2. Sub Parmesan Truffle Fries $1.5. Sub plant-based and gluten free bun for $1.5.
1,000 island, Society Pickles, lettuce, tomato, red onions & your choice of cheese: provolone, white cheddar, swiss, or American
bacon, blue cheese spread, marinated roasted red peppers & crispy onions
bacon, french onion dip, caramelized onions & swiss
American cheese, bacon, jalapeño, smoky BBQ sauce & crispy onions
All plant-based Beyond Burger, cheese, roasted garlic mayo, jalapeño, caramelized onion & pickle
seasoned chips w/ homemade french onion dip
spicy fried, hot honey-buffalo classic, buffalo or smoky BBQ, served with with parmesan ranch
Society fries topped w/ melted homemade pimento cheese TRY THEM LOADED: W/ JALAPENO & CRUMBLED BACON $10
Bowl of seasoned fries with your choice of dipping sauce Additional cost for Parmesan-Truffle Fries +$2.5
slow cooked, char siu glazed pork ribs
perfectly fried and topped with parmesan/lemon OR feta+hot-honey-balsamic reduction
Homemade dressings: Green Goddess (GF), Parmesan Ranch (GF) & Lemon Caesar*(GF) Balsamic (GF, DF) & Red Wine Vinaigrette (GF, DF) Add protein with: fried chicken breast $6 hard boiled egg $2
mixed greens w/ cucumber, tomato & red onion tossed in your choice of dressing
our Martha salad with bacon, blue cheese & hard boiled egg tossed in our Green Goddess dressing
chopped kale, parmesan & buttered bread crumbs tossed in our lemon caesar* dressing
mixed greens with apple slices, spiced cashews, red onions & blue cheese tossed in our Green Goddess dressing
Showing the first 6 menu sections to keep this page fast.
Order Online
Delivery & takeout
🎟️Coupons & Deals
Find savings
⭐Read Reviews
Yelp, Google, TripAdvisor
📍Map & Location
Get directions
📸View Photos
10 photos
Handpicked by cuisine, location, and menu similarity.